• Products
    Digital Trust & Safety Suite

    Expand with confidence, and fight many types of fraud and abuse

    Payment Protection

    Reduce risk and grow revenue

    Content Integrity

    Protect users from spam and scams

    Account Defense

    Stop account takeover attacks

    Latest Product Releases & Enhancements
    Sift Connect
    PSD2 Solution
  • Why Sift
    The Sift Way

    Technology, Community, Partnership

    Commerce Platform Partners

    Low-code integrations for leading commerce platforms

  • Customers
    See case studies by industry

    Sift works for companies across e-commerce, travel, on-demand, and more.

    Featured Customers

    Harry’s

    85% reduction in chargebacks

    Poshmark

    70% less spam content

    Turo

    100% of ATO blocked

  • Resources
    Blog

    Digital Trust & Safety news

    Demos

    Walk-throughs of how Sift works

    Ebooks

    Guides, research, and more

    Infographics

    Data brought to life by design

    One Pagers

    Product and use case info

    Podcasts

    Stories from the fraud front lines

    Videos

    Testimonials and brand stories

    Virtual Events

    Virtual expo and online events

    Webinars

    Insights from industry experts

  • About
    Search Careers

    Make the internet a safer place â€” Grow your career.

    Our Company

    Learn how Sift helps companies grow securely

    Contact Us

    Want to get in touch? We'd love to hear from you

    Partner with Us

    Join the leader in Digital Trust & Safety

  • Request a demo
  • Sign in
Products
  • Digital Trust & Safety Suite
  • Payment Protection
  • Content Integrity
  • Account Defense
  • Latest Releases
  • Sift Connect
  • PSD2 Solution
Why Sift
  • Salesforce
  • Magento
  • Shopify
Customers
Resources
  • Blog
  • Demos
  • Ebooks
  • Infographics
  • One Pagers
  • Podcasts
  • Videos
  • Virtual Events
  • Webinars
About
  • Search Careers
  • Our Company
  • Contact Us
  • Engineering Blog
Request a Demo Sign In
  • Blog Home
  • Digital Trust & Safety
  • Payment Fraud
< prev / next >
Share this article on LinkedIn
Tweet this article
Share this article on Facebook
SOCIALICON
Share this article via email

How Merchants Can Fight (and Win) Friendly Fraud Disputes

By Arwen Heredia  / 

4 Jun 2020

E-commerce merchants know that, despite its affable name, ‘friendly fraud’ is much less friendly than it is frustrating. It’s long been something that online businesses have had to account for and build into fraud prevention strategies, but the global pandemic has driven some companies’ chargeback rates to historically high levels—leaving trust and safety teams with piles of paperwork to work through and a greater risk of incurring penalties, fees, and other losses.

Changing markets, rising chargebacks

In a recent webinar, Sift’s Michelle Arguelles, Sr. Product Manager, and Trust and Safety Architect, Brittany Allen, explained and explored how merchants can protect their businesses against friendly fraud using holistic prevention strategies and carefully crafted dispute responses. This full-view approach proved effective long before shelter-in-place orders ignited the internet economy, but can be particularly useful in the wake of COVID-19. But before digging into the tactics, Allen notes, it’s necessary to understand the context surrounding friendly fraud and the disrupted online marketplace merchants are now operating in—and to do that, we have to turn to the data. 

Sift’s E-Commerce Fraud Tracker uses a 7-day moving average of our global network data to highlight the week-over-week fluctuations taking place across the pandemic-era marketplace. Traffic and transaction volumes have changed significantly across all verticals in the past two-and-a-half months, and friendly fraud has become noticeably more frequent. The spike comes down to two likely culprits: plans getting cancelled due to social distancing requirements, and sudden financial hardship resulting from loss of income sources. 

This new reality means that merchants need an effective internal dispute process in place now more than ever—because despite the light now showing at the end of the quarantine tunnel, e-commerce is nowhere near returning to business as usual.

Creating a friendly fraud “MFA”: Identity, data, and story

When someone commits friendly fraud, they’re trying to get a refund for a product or service they actually received and/or used. And, because we leave such detailed footprints of our online activities every time we interact with a site, there’s a lot of data available to merchants to fight those illegitimate chargebacks—so Allen suggests developing an “internal multi-factor authentication process” that mirrors what many online merchants do anyway to verify customer legitimacy. This information can then be used when trust and safety teams go through the process of disputing chargebacks. Here’s how it works:  

1. Start with identity. In other words, confirm whether the customer logged into an established account with credentials they’ve used before, paid with a known card or method, submitted known billing and mailing address details, or made the purchase using a known device or IP address.

2. Use internal data. As a merchant, you have access to historical details surrounding how this customer has previously interacted with your site—like whether or not they logged in with SSO, what their purchase history looks like, or if they used a unique promo code. You can even dig deeper into that history to check the chargeback’s logic, i.e., have they recently bought a plane ticket and a seating upgrade, but only filed a dispute on the ticket? You should also look for any records, such as proof of download or proof of delivery, as well as any contradictory communications on the part of the customer, to bolster your evidence. 

3. Map out the story of what has occurred. The most important task on the plate of any trust and safety analyst filing a chargeback dispute is to create a clear, concise, and consumable story that explains what’s really going on. Using the relevant information you’ve now collected about the person’s identity and past behavior, write out the chronological events with specific supporting points and evidence, and accompanied by visuals wherever possible. This adds clarity and efficiency to the process, and provides merchants with the compelling evidence necessary to win disputes and recoup revenue.

Extracting evidence using the Sift Console 

For Sift customers, says Michelle Arguelles, it’s especially easy to surface compelling evidence using the platform’s web-based Console. Fraud teams of all sizes can use it to investigate users and get the right evidence for disputes, automate action when chargebacks are received, and monitor chargeback rates with real-time insights. 

Screenshot from the Sift Console

When it comes to fighting friendly fraud, it’s the User Details page of the Sift Console that provides a wealth of data points necessary to create an airtight “internal MFA.” It tells the story behind how and when transactions are considered risky or fraudulent, and can be downloaded as a PDF or selectively screenshotted depending on the evidence you need. For example, you can use the Order History card to prove a customer has placed multiple orders that have not been charged back. You can also dive into orders for more details. The Activity tab is another great resource, providing a complete timeline of user activity, so you can prove their longevity as a customer on your platform.

In addition to providing evidence for disputes, the Console also has reporting features to help you keep track of your performance. Sift Insights is an all-time, real-time reporting tool that gives you transparency into your chargeback rates over time and your performance with disputes you’ve pursued. With to-the-point, detailed information in hand, merchants can successfully dispute more illegitimate chargebacks—ultimately lowering the risk of penalties and losses, giving analysts more time to focus on true fraud, and enabling your business to drive growth. 

Watch Friendly Fraud: How Trust & Safety Experts Win Disputes to see the full Sift Console demo and learn more about optimizing your friendly fraud strategy.

Related

card-not-present fraudchargeback disputeschargebacksdigital frauddigital transactionsDigital Trust and Safetydynamic frictionfalse positivesfraudfraud managementfraud preventionfraud solutionsfriendly fraudhow to file a chargeback disputeInsult Monitormachine learningriskSifttrust and safety

Arwen Heredia

Arwen Heredia is Sift's Sr. Content Marketing Manager. She's a life-long writer, mom of girls, baker, bookworm, and dancer. You will know her by the trail of bobby pins.

  • < prev
  • Blog Home
  • next >
Company
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • News & Press
  • Partner with us
  • Blog
Support
  • Help Center
  • Contact Support
  • System Status
  • Trust & Safety EDU
  • Fraud Management
Developers
  • Overview
  • APIs
  • Client Libraries
  • Integration Guides
  • Tutorials
  • Engineering Blog
Social

Don't miss a thing

Our newsletter delivers industry trends, insights, and more.

You're on the list.

You can unsubscribe at any time. Please see our Website Privacy Notice.

If you are using a screen reader and are having problems using this website, please email support@sift.com for assistance.

© 2021 Sift All Rights Reserved Privacy & Terms

Your information will be used to contact you about our service and subscribe you to our direct marketing communications. You can, of course, unsubscribe at any time. Please see our Website Privacy Notice.