Sift Logo Several blue dots forming a sphere to the left of the word Sift in italic font.
  • Products

    Digital Trust & Safety Suite

    Fight fraud without sacrificing growth

    Learn more →

    Passwordless
    Authentication

    Account
    Defense

    Content
    Integrity

    Payment
    Protection

    Dispute
    Management

    Sift
    Connect

    PSD2
    Solution

    New Releases & Enhancements

  • Partners

    Sift Partner
    Program

    Join the leader in Digital Trust & Safety

    Learn more →

    Commerce platform partners


  • Industries

    One solution, many applications

    Learn how Sift can work for your industry

    Learn more →

    Featured industries


    Fintech

    Retail

    Food & Beverage

  • Customers

    See case studies by industry

    Sift works across every use case and region

    Learn more →

    Featured customers


  • Resources

    Explore our resources

    Access trends, guides, and insights from Sift

    Learn more →

    Blog

    Ebooks

    One Pagers

    Demos

    Videos

    Webinars

    Infographics

    Podcasts

    Trust & Safety University

  • Fraud Center
  • Company

    Why leaders choose Sift

    Technology, community, and partnership

    Learn more →

    Our mission: Help everyone trust the internet


    About

    Careers

    News & Press

Request a demo
Products
  • Digital Trust & Safety Suite
  • Passwordless Authentication
  • Account Defense
  • Content Integrity
  • Payment Protection
  • Dispute Management
  • Sift Connect
  • PSD2 Solution
  • New Releases & Enchancements
Why Sift
  • Salesforce
  • Magento
  • Shopify
Industries
  • Fintech
  • Retail
  • Food & Beverage
Customers
Resources
  • Blog
  • Ebooks
  • One Pagers
  • Demos
  • Videos
  • Webinars
  • Infographics
  • Podcasts
  • Trust and Safety University
Fraud Center
About
  • Search Careers
  • Our Company
  • Contact Us
  • Engineering Blog
Request a DemoSign In
  • Blog Home
  • Fraud
< prev / next >
Share this article on LinkedIn
Tweet this article
Share this article on Facebook
SOCIALICON
Share this article via email

The Hidden Operational Costs of Fraud

By Evan Schuman  / 

18 Nov 2016

Evan Schuman is a guest contributor to the Sift Science blog.


It’s no secret that fraud is costly for online businesses. But are you tracking exactly where your money is going? A new report from Javelin research found that fraud costs merchants more than 7.5% of their annual revenue –  a figure computed by looking at a combination of fraud management costs, false positives, and chargeback losses.

The biggest surprise? “The majority of these costs came from fraud management expenditures, accounting for around 75% of costs,” according to the report. In fact, the study discovered that fraud management eats up a larger and larger portion of merchants’ overall operational costs. “Digital goods merchants are still at the top of the list (23%), followed by hybrid merchants (16.6%) and physical goods merchants (14.9%), increasing from 20%, 13%, and 14%, respectively in the previous year.”

hidden-cost-of-fraud
Image: 401calculator.org

We talked to Al Pascual, a Javelin research director and head of their fraud and security coverage, about how to approach the hidden costs of fraud.

Fraud’s hidden costs are operational

We already know that online fraud prevention is all about degrees. There’s no perfect setting that will stop all criminal activity and permit all legitimate transactions, so fraud teams find themselves balancing a bias toward stopping more fraud (and, in so doing, blocking some legitimate transactions) with letting more legit actions happen (which naturally lets more fraud through).

Managing the tug-of-war on fraud settings can be costly in and of itself. Set those settings too strictly generated some obvious losses (a customer whose transaction gets rejected takes her money and gives it to a competitor) and some less-obvious ones, such as a lot of customer service time being gobbled up by angry customers wanting to have their transaction go through. And then, if you have a top-notch customer service department, you’re also spending money on handing out deep discount coupons as apologies for the customer inconvenience.

And this doesn’t even get into the huge cost of hiring people to manually review suspicious transactions to determine whether they should be accepted or rejected. Earlier this year, Sift Science found that 59% of online businesses facing fraud were concerned about spending too much money on manual review.

“A good part of our fraud spend is on the people side, on operations,” Pascual said. “It’s a constant tradeoff between legitimate transaction volume and the acceptable amount of fraud.”

Reallocating fraud spend

Pascual has a concrete suggestion for how to manage these challenges: “take money from customer service” to pay for more relaxed fraud settings. That idea has a lot of good thought behind it. From a spreadsheet perspective, relaxing those settings will free up customer service to help customers, while also reducing the number of customers your systems have made angry. Also, no need to dole out those discount coupons.

But there’s another point to keep in mind when navigating the balance between stopping fraud and enabling sales. Not every company needs to be as worried about the knock-on effects of false positives (namely, angry customers going to a competitor), Pascual argues. He advises clients to take a serious and meaningful look at competitive situations, zeroing in on the specific products they’re offering when evaluating risk. What are the chances of a customer who is falsely rejected due to overly stringent fraud settings taking their business elsewhere? “In a space where there are not a lot of competitors, you can be a little more cavalier with false positives,” he said.

 

Related

manual review

Evan Schuman

Evan Schuman has covered IT issues for a lot longer than he'll ever admit. The founding editor of retail technology site StorefrontBacktalk, he's been a columnist for CBSNews.com, RetailWeek, Computerworld, and eWeek.

  • < prev
  • Blog Home
  • next >
Company
  • About Us
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • News & Press
  • Partner with us
  • Blog
Support
  • Help Center
  • Contact Support
  • System Status
  • Trust & Safety University
  • Fraud Management
Developers
  • Overview
  • APIs
  • Client Libraries
  • Integration Guides
  • Tutorials
  • Engineering Blog
Social

Don't miss a thing

Our newsletter delivers industry trends, insights, and more.

You're on the list.

You can unsubscribe at any time. Please see our Website Privacy Notice.

If you are using a screen reader and are having problems using this website, please email support@sift.com for assistance.

© 2022 Sift All Rights Reserved Privacy & Terms

Your information will be used to contact you about our service and subscribe you to our direct marketing communications. You can, of course, unsubscribe at any time. Please see our Website Privacy Notice.